Reading literacy instruction in English-language countries: similarities and differences Publications
Publication Details
Using data from PIRLS 2016, this paper presents a comparison of the instructional practices used by teachers in English-language countries and jurisdictions when teaching reading comprehension, drawing attention to the similarities and differences across them.
Author(s): Megan Chamberlain with Jessica Forkert, Evidence, Data and Knowledge, Ministry of Education.
Date Published: August 2019
Summary
This paper extrapolates on recent evidence reported by researchers at Liège University (Belgium), who found that overall, the English-speaking systems were well-placed with implementing known effective literacy practices compared with German-speaking and French-speaking education systems. The English-language countries, are representative of both Northern and Southern hemisphere countries; low and high-performing systems, and have relatively diverse student populations. Of the 10 countries/jurisdictions considered here, students in seven of them achieved, on average, significantly higher reading scores than New Zealand Year 5 students.
Key Findings
Overall, there are more similarities than differences in the instructional practices used by teachers in English-language countries. However, there were some practices and approaches where New Zealand stands out quite markedly — by either carrying out or using a particular approach or not using an approach. Compared with their peers in most of the other English-language countries,
- teach reading to children in same ability groups
- ask their students to read silently on their own.
New Zealand teachers were less likely to…
- teach reading to the whole class
- ask their students to read aloud
- teach new vocabulary systematically
- use longer fiction chapter books as part of their reading instruction.
Navigation
Contact us
Education data requests
If you have any questions about education data please email us at Requests Data and Insights