Education Counts

Page navigation links

  • Education Counts Logo
  • Skip to Primary Navigation Menu
  • Skip to Secondary Navigation Menu
  • Skip to search
  • Skip to content

Site Search

Site Search

Site navigation menus

  • Know your region
  • Find your nearest school
  • Early learning services
  • Directories
  • Publications
  • Statistics
  • Topics
  • Data Services

Search the education counts website

Find pages with

Narrow results by:

Evaluation of the Pacific Early Learning Services Publications

Publication Details

Pacific Early Learning Services provide culturally responsive early learning environments that strengthen Pacific identities, languages and cultures. This evaluation was informed by the Pacific Value-for-Investment Model (P-VIM) and included a Social Return on Investment analysis (SROI). While the evaluation was undertaken during a time of significant change and there are some caveats related to the findings, this evaluation is the first to utilise this combination of analyses in a Pacific context and lays the foundation for further similarly robust analysis in support of the impact and value of Pacific work in education.

Author(s): TIRIA (previously Malatest International) for the Ministry of Education

Date Published: November 2026

Executive summary

Background

Pacific Early Learning Services (PELSs) play a crucial role in providing culturally responsive early learning environments that strengthen Pacific identities, languages and cultures.

In response to historically high closure rates compared to other services, the Ministry of Education (MoE) invested in a targeted package of supports to help PELSs remain viable during and beyond the impacts of COVID-19. MoE’s support consisted of establishing a network of Pacific Early Learning Advisors (ELAs) and a Learning Support Advisor to provide culturally responsive guidance, practical support, and professional learning development (PLD) and learning opportunities to help PELSs strengthen their governance and management capability, financial viability and service sustainability.

Evaluation approach and scope

The evaluation was undertaken between January and June 2026, guided by the Pacific Value-for-Investment Model (P-VIM)1 and inclusive of a Social Return on Investment (SROI) analysis. Evidence was drawn from in-depth interviews with MoE ELAs (7), MoE Pacific national office staff and other stakeholders (7), MoE regulatory staff (3). The interview participant numbers are representative, given that the population of interest is small. However, it should be noted that the response rate for the online survey of PELSs was relatively low at (N=28) and this evaluation acknowledges this limitation. Further the scope of the evaluation excluded primary data collection from the families who benefit from the existence of PELS. The evaluation is informed by relevant programme documents and internal administrative data. Evaluation findings were triangulated across these sources and synthesised to inform evaluative judgements against co-created Value-for-Investment criteria and standards.

While the P-VIM approach combined multiple sources of evidence to inform systematic and robust evaluative judgements, it is important to note that the evaluation was conducted during a period of significant systemic change (including the disestablishment of the ELA role and the transfer of regulatory functions to the Education Review Office (ERO)) and engagement with PELS learners and families was not feasible. Consequently, evaluative judgements about elements of the programme’s ‘effectiveness’ have been interpreted as enabling conditions that support quality early learning rather than as direct empirical measures of child- and family-level outcomes.

Answering the key evaluation questions

To what extent were the intended outcomes achieved?

The PELS programme strengthened the capability and confidence of PELSs to lead, manage and sustain their services. Through trusted, culturally grounded support, ELAs helped governance boards and leaders clarify roles, strengthen decision-making, improve financial oversight and respond to operational challenges before they escalated. In some cases, this helped PELSs address significant governance and management issues, reducing the risk of regulatory action or closure. Likewise, administration data from 2024/25 indicates that the regulatory compliance of PELSs is comparable to that of other early childhood education services. This demonstrates an improvement over time in understanding what is required for regulatory compliance to stay sustainable.

The PELS programme improved PELSs' engagement with MoE. Trusted relationships shifted engagement from reactive, compliance-focused interactions to proactive, more open conversations centred on capability building and continuous improvement. For regulatory staff, this meant greater visibility of emerging challenges and more opportunity to work with PELSs to address issues before they escalated. ELAs acted as trusted cultural brokers, helping ELSs navigate regulatory and funding processes, connect with specialist expertise and access culturally responsive PLD tailored to their needs.

Beyond organisational capability, the programme strengthened the conditions that support positive outcomes for Pacific children and families. Pacific language, culture and identity remained central to PELS delivery, while PELSs were better equipped to identify and respond to children's learning support needs, work alongside families and support successful transitions to school. However, access to specialists, learning support and other services remained uneven across the country, meaning the support available to Pacific children and families continued to vary depending on where they lived. ELAs also described PELSs as trusted community hubs that supported families beyond children's education, connecting them with wider services and community networks.

The PELS programme created value for MoE. Through their trusted relationships and deep understanding of Pacific communities, ELAs provided sector intelligence that improved the MoE's understanding of the Pacific early learning sector and informed specific policy and operational decisions. Further, the economic analysis estimates that, across the full 4-year investment period, MoE-funded advisory support for PELS achieved a SROI ratio range of approximately $15-$16:1.2 This indicates that every $1 invested by MoE generated approximately $15-$16 in social value over the life of the investment period. Refer to Chapter 7 for further details.
Further, after the ELA service was implemented, the 2024/25 demonstrated that the regulatory compliance of PELSs is comparable to that of other early childhood education services. Together, these changes strengthened organisational, cultural, relational, regulatory, economic and institutional capability across the Pacific early learning system.

While these improvements were evident across some PELSs, they were not universal. The extent of change varied depending on local context, service capability and wider workforce, funding and education system challenges, many of which sit beyond the influence of the PELS programme. In addition, much of the progress achieved remains closely linked to the relationships, knowledge and support provided by ELAs, highlighting the need to further embed capability within PELSs and the wider education sector so improvements can be sustained over time.

What explains regional differences?

Regional differences reflected local context, rather than differences in programme delivery: Regional variation reflected differences in Pacific communities, workforce availability, geography and local priorities rather than differences in how the programme was delivered. ELAs tailored their support to local contexts, drawing on local knowledge, church networks and regional relationships to respond to the different needs of PELSs across Aotearoa New Zealand. This flexibility was a key strength of the PELS programme and suggests any future support should continue to enable locally responsive approaches rather than adopt a one-size-fits-all model.

What enabled and constrained PELS’s success?

Trusted, culturally grounded relationships were the mechanisms through which ELAs and the programme created value. The programme's success was underpinned by trusted relationships, Pacific-led delivery and culturally grounded ways of working. These relationships were not simply about positive engagement. Trust enabled PELSs to raise concerns earlier and share information more openly, giving ELAs and regulatory staff greater visibility of emerging issues and creating opportunities to provide support before problems escalated or required formal regulatory intervention. Likewise, as previously noted, MoE data indicates that over time PELs demonstrated a level of regulatory adherence similar to that of other Early Childhood Education services.

ELAs worked alongside PELSs and other MoE staff to navigate regulatory and operational requirements, build governance and leadership capability, and connect services with specialist advice, PLD and other support where needed. Pacific languages, values and community knowledge enabled this support to be delivered in ways that were trusted, relevant and culturally responsive. However, workforce shortages, funding pressures, volunteer governance models and wider challenges across the education sector continued to constrain long-term sustainability for ELAs and PELSs.

The evaluation identified several factors that consistently contributed to the programme’s success:

  • Trusted, relationship-based support that encouraged PELSs to seek advice earlier and work proactively with MoE.
  • Pacific-led, culturally grounded delivery that combined Pacific languages, values and ways of working with practical support.
  • Locally responsive delivery that adapted support to the needs of different Pacific communities rather than applying a one-size-fits-all approach.
  • Tailored PLD and specialist support, delivered by Pacific providers where possible, that responded directly to the needs identified by PELSs.
  • Strong collaboration between ELAs, regulatory staff, national teams and specialist PLD providers, enabling more coordinated support.

The evaluation also identified challenges that limited the programme’s ability to achieve and sustain outcomes:

  • Workforce shortages, including an ageing Pacific language workforce and difficulties recruiting and retaining qualified teachers and leaders.
  • Funding pressures that limited the financial sustainability of some PELSs and their ability to participate in ongoing capability development.
  • Volunteer governance models, resulting in variable governance capability and high turnover of board members.
  • Education system arrangements that do not always align with Pacific models of service delivery or recognise the wider community role PELSs play.
  • Uneven access to specialist learning support and Pacific language pathways meant outcomes continued to vary depending on where children and families lived.

These constraints sit largely beyond the influence of PELSs and require broader system responses if the gains achieved through the programme are to be sustained.

What worked well and what can be improved for any future Pacific-led support?

The PELSs demonstrated that relationship-based, culturally responsive support can strengthen PELSs and improve how MoE works with Pacific communities. ELAs acted as trusted cultural brokers, helping MoE better understand the Pacific early learning sector and informing more responsive policy and operational support. To sustain these gains, future investment should focus on retaining dedicated Pacific advisory capability, embedding culturally responsive approaches across MoE systems, strengthening workforce sustainability and addressing wider structural barriers affecting PELSs.

The evaluation identified several opportunities to strengthen any future investment:

  • Retain dedicated Pacific early learning advisory capability to preserve trusted relationships, Pacific sector knowledge and culturally responsive support.
  • Strengthen workforce sustainability and leadership pathways to address workforce shortages, support succession planning and protect Pacific language capability.
  • Support PELSs through future system changes by ensuring continuity of relationships and culturally responsive guidance during transitions, including changes to regulatory arrangements.
  • Embed culturally responsive approaches more consistently across government systems so the capability developed through the programme becomes part of everyday practice rather than relying on individual advisors.
  • Continue building organisational capability within PELSs so knowledge, confidence and leadership are sustained beyond individual advisors and future external support.

What unintended outcomes occurred?

The PELS programme generated benefits beyond its original focus on strengthening PELSs. Strengthening governance and organisational capability also contributed to improvements in curriculum practice, stronger collaboration across the education system and increased MoE understanding of Pacific early learning. The evaluation also found that relationship-based support improved how PELSs engaged with MoE. All ELAs gave examples of PELSs moving from seeking help only during crises to engaging earlier, sharing challenges openly and viewing MoE as a trusted partner rather than solely a regulator. These wider benefits demonstrate that investing in organisational capability and trusted relationships can create lasting value across children, families, communities and the education system.

Overview and implications for future investment

Overall, the programme achieved most of its intended outcomes and created value for PELSs, communities and the education system. Through trusted, Pacific-led support, the programme strengthened governance and leadership capability, improved organisational resilience, expanded access to culturally responsive professional learning and specialist support, and strengthened relationships between PELS and MoE. It also improved MoE's understanding of the Pacific early learning sector and informed the development of specific policy and operational support. These gains were widespread but not universal, reflecting differences in PELS capability, local context and broader workforce and education sector challenges.

The programme's greatest contribution was not simply helping PELS meet regulatory requirements. It demonstrated that trusted relationships, grounded in Pacific languages, values and ways of working, can strengthen organisational capability, support more open and earlier engagement with MoE, and create value that extends beyond individual PELS.

However, the evaluation also found that many of these gains remain vulnerable. With the ELA roles having concluded in June 2026 and wider education system reforms underway, there is a risk that trusted relationships, institutional knowledge and sector capability developed through the programme will diminish unless deliberate arrangements are made to retain them. Long-term sustainability will also depend on addressing the wider workforce and system challenges that remain beyond the programme’s direct influence.

The implications for future investment are therefore not necessarily to replicate the ELA role exactly as it existed, but to retain and embed the features that enabled it to create value: trusted relationships, Pacific leadership, locally responsive delivery and deliberate investment in building capability that can be sustained over time. Preserving these strengths, alongside action on wider workforce and education sector constraints, provides the strongest foundations for sustaining and extending the value created through the programme.

Footnotes

  1. Perese, L., King, J., Stephen, J., Pio-Bentley, F., Davies, P., & McLeod, D. (2025). The Pacific Value-for-Investment Model. TIRIA Ltd, Julian King & Associates and Sapere, for Auckland Council.
  2. The SROI analysis was undertaken across the full 4-year investment period and estimates the social value generated for participants, whānau, communities, and the wider education system relative to the investment made by MoE. The input values were derived using 2024/25 programme data as it was the most accurate.

Navigation

  • Pacific

Downloads

  • Full report (PDF, 6.0 MB)

Contact us

Education data requests
If you have any questions about education data please email us at Requests Data and Insights

Home Close Menu
  • Know your Region Show submenu
  • Find your nearest school Show submenu
  • Early Learning Services Show submenu
  • Directories Show submenu
    • Early Childhood Services Directory – APIShow submenu
    • Early Childhood ServicesShow submenu
    • School Directory – APIShow submenu
    • New Zealand SchoolsShow submenu
    • Māori Schools DirectoryShow submenu
      • Māori Schools DirectoryShow submenu
    • Pacific Schools DirectoryShow submenu
    • Tertiary ProvidersShow submenu
    • School Mergers, Closures & NewShow submenu
  • Publications Show submenu
    • Early Childhood EducationShow submenu
    • MāoriShow submenu
      • KME & MMEShow submenu
      • English-medium EducationShow submenu
      • KME or MME, & English-mediumShow submenu
    • SchoolingShow submenu
      • LearnersShow submenu
        • Learners in GeneralShow submenu
        • Education | Learning OutcomesShow submenu
        • Student Engagement | BehaviourShow submenu
      • Learning Support & WellbeingShow submenu
      • WorkforceShow submenu
      • Parents & WhānauShow submenu
      • School Networks | SystemShow submenu
      • CurriculumShow submenu
      • Digital TechnologyShow submenu
      • Large Scale International StudiesShow submenu
    • PacificShow submenu
    • Tertiary EducationShow submenu
      • COVID-19Show submenu
      • LearnersShow submenu
      • Beyond StudyShow submenu
        • DestinationsShow submenu
        • EmploymentShow submenu
        • Income & EarningsShow submenu
        • Other Economic OutcomesShow submenu
        • Social OutcomesShow submenu
      • MonitoringShow submenu
      • Literacy & NumeracyShow submenu
      • Research Performance/FundingShow submenu
      • SystemShow submenu
      • Annual ReportsShow submenu
      • Occasional PapersShow submenu
      • NZ University RankingsShow submenu
      • e-learningShow submenu
    • Learning SupportShow submenu
    • InternationalShow submenu
    • Publication SeriesShow submenu
  • Statistics Show submenu
    • Action Plan for Pacific Education measurement framework dataShow submenu
    • Active non-enrolment cases (NEN)Show submenu
    • Annual monitoring reading recoveryShow submenu
    • Apprenticeship boostShow submenu
    • Attainment of 18-year-oldsShow submenu
    • AttendanceShow submenu
    • Beyond studyShow submenu
    • Daily attendance dashboardShow submenu
    • Early learning participationShow submenu
    • Early leaving exemptionsShow submenu
    • ECE financesShow submenu
    • ECE servicesShow submenu
    • ECE staffingShow submenu
    • Entering & leaving teachingShow submenu
    • Financial resourcingShow submenu
    • Financial support for tertiary studentsShow submenu
    • First Year Fees Free tertiary educationShow submenu
    • Funding to schoolsShow submenu
    • HomeschoolingShow submenu
    • Initial teacher education statisticsShow submenu
    • International students in NZShow submenu
    • Language use in ECEShow submenu
    • Māori language in schoolingShow submenu
    • Micro-credentials & training schemesShow submenu
    • National school roll projectionsShow submenu
    • Number of schoolsShow submenu
    • NZ's workplace-based learnersShow submenu
    • Ongoing resourcing schemeShow submenu
    • Pacific language in schoolingShow submenu
    • Pathways from Year 11Show submenu
    • Per student funding for schoolsShow submenu
    • School board representationShow submenu
    • School boardsShow submenu
    • School donations schemeShow submenu
    • School leaver pathwaysShow submenu
    • School leaver's attainment & destinationsShow submenu
    • School rollsShow submenu
    • School subject enrolmentShow submenu
    • Stand-downs, suspensions, exclusions & expulsionsShow submenu
    • Teacher numbersShow submenu
      • 2021Show submenu
      • 2020Show submenu
    • Teacher turnoverShow submenu
    • Tertiary achievement & attainmentShow submenu
    • Tertiary enrolments in language courses, including Te Reo Māori coursesShow submenu
    • Tertiary participationShow submenu
    • Tertiary population dataShow submenu
    • Tertiary researchShow submenu
    • Tertiary staffingShow submenu
      • How does New Zealand’s tertiary education staffing compare internationally?Show submenu
    • Tertiary summary tablesShow submenu
    • Transient studentsShow submenu
    • Traumatic incidentsShow submenu
    • University rankings fact sheetsShow submenu
    • Vocational education & trainingShow submenu
  • Topics Show submenu
    • He Whakaaro: Education InsightsShow submenu
  • Data Services Show submenu

Site information

  • Site map
  • Contact us
  • About this site
  • Glossary
  • Copyright, Legal & Privacy
  • Links
  • © Education Counts 2026
  • Ministry of Education logo.
  • New Zealand Government logo.
Scroll to top of page