Publications

Comparing Modern Apprenticeships and industry training

Publication Details

The Modern Apprenticeships programme was introduced nation-wide in 2001 to address participation problems in workplace industry training by young people. It is aimed at 15 to 21 year olds wishing to participate in formalised workplace-based training, and is intended to lead to national qualifications.

Author(s): Paul Mahoney, Senior Research Analyst, Tertiary Sector Performance, Analysis and Reporting [Ministry of Education]

Date Published: July 2010

Appendix


Appendix Table 1 – Model 1 cohort selection - industry training and Modern Apprenticeships comparison
Cohort selection – Model 1Industry training learnersModern Apprentices
Agriculture Industry Training Organisation Incorporated2,525991
Aviation, Tourism and Travel Training Organisation Incorporated377209
Boating Industries Association of New Zealand Incorporated9529
Building & Construction Industry Training Organisation Incorporated2,9781,990
Creative Trades Industry Training Organisations Inc352222
Electricity Supply Industry Training Organisation Incorporated76452
Electrotechnology Industry Training Organisation Incorporated2,204808
Forest Industry Training and Education Council of New Zealand Incorporated653825
Hospitality Standards Institute1,234505
InfraTrain New Zealand Limited46288
Joinery Industry Training Organisation Incorporated370271
Master Plumbers, Gasfitters & Drainlayers New Zealand Incorporated587164
NZ Commercial Road Transport Industry Training Organisation Incorporated646144
NZ Motor Industry Training Organisation Incorporated2,1451,506
New Zealand Engineering, Food and Manufacturing Industry Training Organisation1,0622,133
New Zealand Extractive Industries Training Organisation Incorporated15530
New Zealand Flooring Industry Training Organisation Incorporated10318
New Zealand Furniture Industry Training Organisation Incorporated73132
New Zealand Horticulture Industry Training Organisation Incorporated68683
New Zealand Industry Training Organisation Incorporated56111
New Zealand Sports Turf Industry Training Organisation Incorporated15131
Printing and Allied Industries Training Council Incorporated57200
Public Sector Training Organisation130200
Retail Training New   Zealand Incorporated163168
Total16,49612,910


Appendix Table 2 – Model 2 cohort  selection  - Modern Apprentices by  coordinator type
Modern Apprenticeships industryITO coordinated learnersNon-ITO coordinated learners
Agriculture819160
Building & construction1,104883
Contracting2808
Horticulture65328
Hospitality371133
Joinery30246
Motor engineering900606
Painting & decorating8204
Printing18416
Retail9969
Road transport9846
Total4,5462,399

 

Appendix Table 3 – Model 1 cohort regression output
Parameter   DF Estimate Standard
   Error 		Wald
   Chi-Square 		Pr > ChiSq
Intercept  1-0.18940.11362.77890.0955
Study rate0.3 or less 1-0.002750.08540.00100.9743
 0.4 1-0.09870.07291.83330.1757
 0.5 1-0.16190.05698.09360.0044
 0.7 or more 1-0.29700.045742.2252<.0001
Previous qualificationNCEA level 2 10.33560.041066.8733<.0001
 NCEA level 3 10.41700.053760.2479<.0001
 Below degree level post-school quals 10.36660.055543.5825<.0001
 Degree level quals 1-0.02920.15790.03430.8531
 No previous qualifications 1-0.32500.048644.6617<.0001
 not specified 1-0.12210.04457.53460.0061
NQF level4 1-0.07970.05811.87760.1706
GenderF 10.007080.05240.01830.8924
Ethnic groupMāori 1-0.39940.043882.9997<.0001
 Not Stated 1-0.08470.07161.40080.2366
 Other 1-0.03720.08450.19380.6598
 Pasifika 1-0.61290.093942.6172<.0001
Programme credits161 to 200 10.51050.084236.7877<.0001
 201 or more 10.55420.081745.9733<.0001
 41 to 80 10.40220.092918.7612<.0001
 81 to 120 10.05570.07640.53170.4659
RegionBay of Plenty  1-0.01840.05620.10720.7434
 Canterbury  1-0.07070.05061.95070.1625
 Central 10.26360.056721.5955<.0001
 Eastern Coast 10.15630.06775.33290.0209
 Nelson / Marlborough / West Coast 10.23930.067112.71020.0004
 Northland 10.10940.07132.35880.1246
 South Taranaki District 10.19380.14251.84920.1739
 Southern 10.20940.052016.2008<.0001
 Waikato  10.05310.05310.99850.3177
 Wellington  1-0.08930.05702.45350.1173
OrganisationAgriculture  1-1.20980.1035136.6798<.0001
 Aviation, Tourism and Travel  1-0.05170.15270.11470.7348
 Boating Industries  10.09230.74420.01540.9013
 Building & Construction  1-0.36120.070925.9664<.0001
 Creative Trades  1-0.16030.14821.17080.2792
 Electricity Supply  1-1.31460.288320.7971<.0001
 Electrotechnology  1-0.53350.077247.7544<.0001
 Forest Industry Training  1-1.46580.162381.5177<.0001
 Hospitality  1-0.63950.134022.7778<.0001
 InfraTrain  10.36520.37680.93920.3325
 Joinery  10.77450.152325.8550<.0001
 Master Plumbers, Gasfitters & Drainlayers  1-0.25990.12354.42920.0353
 NZ Commercial Road Transport  1-1.93310.1515162.7864<.0001
 New Zealand Engineering, Food and Manufacturing  1-0.59750.101934.3790<.0001
 Extractive Industries  1-1.60050.242243.6787<.0001
 Flooring  1-0.94150.87791.15010.2835
 Furniture  1-1.02040.52523.77470.0520
 Horticulture

 

1-2.24200.447025.1587<.0001
 New Zealand Industry Training Organisation

 

10.20130.21980.83840.3598
 Sports Turf

 

1-0.86190.68951.56240.2113
 Printing and Allied Industries

 

10.48420.30402.53740.1112
 Public Sector

 

10.23590.21171.24120.2652
 Retail

 

1-0.04160.18890.04840.8258
 Seafood Industry Council

 

1-0.08900.28700.09610.7566
Age at entry17 and 18 years

 

10.11700.04048.39350.0038
 19 and 20 years

 

10.13840.04409.87150.0017
 21 years

 

10.20270.057212.55680.0004
Minimum year learner2002

 

10.23620.050821.5880<.0001
 2003

 

10.18570.037224.9730<.0001
 2005

 

1-0.32780.035684.6616<.0001
FundModern Apprenticeships

 

1-0.005950.07570.00620.9373
Organisation * FundAgriculture

MA

1-0.04090.14330.08150.7753
 Aviation, Tourism and Travel

MA

1-0.85600.229113.96240.0002
 Boating Industries

MA

1-0.69550.75160.85640.3547
 Building & Construction

MA

1-0.33170.098411.37080.0007
 Creative Trades

MA

10.74190.210612.41400.0004
 Electricity Supply

MA

10.95420.30859.57020.0020
 Electrotechnology

MA

10.46690.119315.3254<.0001
 Forest Industry Training

MA

11.00660.183230.1896<.0001
 Hospitality

MA

10.80860.180220.1305<.0001
 InfraTrain

MA

1-2.12010.412326.4452<.0001
 Joinery

MA

10.12720.20770.37520.5402
 Master Plumbers, Gasfitters & Drainlayers

MA

1-0.18250.21370.72950.3930
 NZ Commercial Road Transport

MA

10.76000.28247.24160.0071
 New Zealand Engineering, Food and Manufacturing

MA

10.29070.12285.60580.0179
 Extractive Industries

MA

10.58560.49101.42230.2330
 Flooring

MA

11.17800.88781.76060.1846
 Furniture

MA

11.34990.56825.64320.0175
 Horticulture

MA

10.36150.46130.61410.4333
 New Zealand Industry Training Organisation

MA

1-11.6147121.50.00910.9239
 Sports Turf

MA

10.54630.71580.58250.4453
 Printing and Allied Industries

MA

1-0.14250.34680.16880.6812
 Public Sector

MA

1-0.63240.26265.80040.0160
 Retail

MA

1-1.51300.298525.6929<.0001
 Seafood Industry Council

MA

1-1.56460.62896.18850.0129


Appendix Table 4 – Model 2 cohort  regression output
   Parameter  DF Estimate Standard
 Error 		Wald
 Chi-Square 		Pr > ChiSq
Intercept 10.21790.24180.81160.3677
Study rate (STM)0.3 or less10.50200.150011.19640.0008
 0.410.27110.12934.39530.0360
 0.510.33050.11118.85200.0029
 0.7 or more1-0.25230.077310.66610.0011
Previous qualification6th Form or equiv10.30050.081513.60720.0002
 7th Form or equiv10.49630.116818.0605<.0001
 Below degree level post-school quals10.30990.11357.45490.0063
 Degree level quals1-0.21600.48250.20040.6544
 No previous qualifications1-0.12310.08921.90390.1676
 not specified1-0.05800.08770.43790.5081
NQF level41-0.34920.17024.20900.0402
GenderF10.29480.10687.61750.0058
Ethnic groupMāori1-0.52640.085837.6341<.0001
 Not Stated10.10210.14670.48470.4863
 Other10.14170.21530.43320.5104
 Pasifika1-0.89440.215017.3075<.0001
Programme credits161 to 20010.11230.13740.66790.4138
 201 or more10.19240.14621.73270.1881
 41 to 801-0.21160.75300.07900.7787
 81 to 1201-0.61260.191610.22220.0014
RegionBay of Plenty 10.36880.101113.32260.0003
 Canterbury 1-0.01650.11650.02020.8871
 Central10.22350.12163.37900.0660
 Eastern Coast10.38290.116410.81930.0010
 Nelson / Marlborough / West Coast10.33330.12097.60190.0058
 Northland10.40010.125510.16900.0014
 South Taranaki District1-0.10090.36060.07830.7796
 Southern10.31910.11228.09340.0044
 Waikato 10.31010.10798.26220.0040
 Wellington 10.002450.12890.00040.9848
Industry nameAgriculture1-1.68280.1289170.3261<.0001
 Building & construction1-0.60920.087548.5159<.0001
 Contracting1-1.90830.214579.1707<.0001
 Horticulture1-2.09290.1417218.2705<.0001
 Hospitality1-0.27440.15773.02640.0819
 Joinery10.41310.17715.44060.0197
 Painting & decorating10.001800.19820.00010.9927
 Printing10.10770.19410.30800.5789
 Retail1-2.62600.295179.1681<.0001
 Road transport1-1.47990.282627.4141<.0001
Age at entry17 and 18 years10.08760.07461.37850.2404
 19 and 20 years10.11310.08391.81780.1776
 21 years10.18860.12572.25160.1335
Minimum year learner200210.15440.08173.57340.0587
 200310.11100.07802.02340.1549
 20051-0.29630.077814.50390.0001


Appendix Table 5 – Modern Apprenticeships cohort by industry and by coordinator provider type
IndustryITO as MACNon-ITO MACTotalITO as MAC (%)Non-ITO MAC (%)
Agriculture81916097922.58.9
Building & construction1104883198730.349.2
Contracting28082887.70.4
Horticulture6532868117.91.6
Hospitality37113350410.27.4
Joinery302462760.813.7
Painting & decorating82042120.211.4
Printing184162005.00.9
Retail99691682.73.8
Road transport98461442.72.6
Grand Total364617935439100.0100.0

 

Appendix Table 6 – Modern Apprenticeships cohort by previous qualifications and by coordinator provider type
Previous qualificationITO as MACNon-ITO MACTotalITO as MAC (%)Non-ITO MAC (%)
not specified1027604163128.233.7
No previous qualifications60426586916.614.8
NCEA level 1833429126222.823.9
NCEA level 269225494619.014.2
NCEA level 3273923657.55.1
Below degree level post-school quals2051413465.67.9
Degree level quals128200.30.4

 

Appendix Table 7 – All Modern Apprenticeships starters 2002 - 2005 by previous qualifications and by coordinator provider type
Previous qualificationITO as MACNon-ITO MACTotalITO as MAC (%)Non-ITO MAC (%)
not specified20351137317228.719.5
No previous qualifications995726172114.012.4
NCEA level 116931650334323.828.3
NCEA level 212751299257418.022.2
NCEA level 353457111057.59.8
Below degree level post-school quals5394419807.67.6
Degree level quals2916450.40.3

 

Appendix Table 8 – Modern Apprenticeships cohort by ethnic group and by coordinator provider type
Previous qualificationITO as MACNon-ITO MACTotalITO as MAC (%)Non-ITO MAC (%)
European / Pakeha28881257414579.270.1
Māori44033177112.118.5
Pasifika112371493.12.1
Other5716731.60.9
Not stated1491523014.18.5
Grand Total364617935439100.0100.0

 


Contact Us

For more publication-related information, please email: information.officer@minedu.govt.nz

Search Publications

 Copyright © Education Counts 2011   |   Contact information.officer@minedu.govt.nz for enquiries.